Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
123 lines (72 loc) · 2.13 KB

File metadata and controls

123 lines (72 loc) · 2.13 KB

Stop Rules

This document defines explicit termination conditions for analysis within the Matrix repository.

STOP is not failure. STOP is a valid outcome.


Scope

These rules apply to:

  • fillets
  • gap artifacts
  • stress tests
  • any diagnostic or analytic activity

No artifact overrides STOP.


Mandatory STOP Conditions

Analysis must stop if any of the following holds.

1. No Isolatable Transfer

If no specific illegitimate transfer can be clearly identified.

Vague suspicion is insufficient.


2. Non-Falsifiability

If the diagnosis cannot fail under any conceivable counterfactual.

Unfalsifiable analysis is inadmissible.


3. Pure Decomposition

If further analysis only refines language, adds distinctions, or increases detail without changing epistemic outcome.


4. Speculative Bridging

If continuation requires speculative ontological, normative, or metaphysical bridges.


5. Authority Substitution

If critique begins to function as implicit authority or moral leverage.


Silence Clause

Silence is permitted. Closure is not required. Unresolved status is acceptable.


Governance Rule

STOP decisions are final unless new admissible material is introduced.

Persistence does not reopen analysis.


Meta-Constraint

These rules apply to themselves.

No exemption is implicit.

STOP Rules

STOP rules are structural safeguards. They are not conclusions and do not imply error.

SR-01 — Implicit Authority

Triggered when a claim acquires authority without explicit justification of scope and responsibility.

SR-02 — Illegitimate Transfer

Triggered when a transfer between epistemic levels is performed implicitly or without binding conditions.

SR-03 — Self-Sealing Reasoning

Triggered when a claim justifies itself by reference to its own coherence, acceptance, or persistence.

SR-04 — Exhausted Decomposition

Triggered when further analysis adds no new diagnostic distinction.

Effect of STOP

When STOP is triggered:

  • analysis halts
  • no verdict is produced
  • Absence or Gap is recorded
  • responsibility remains external to the Matrix