building=service icon?

[matkoniecz]

Modify apartments-1-story by removing door and window?

[enzet]

Hi, @matkoniecz! Great idea. This issue is only about an icon? If so, I probably will move this to Röntgen repository.

[matkoniecz]

yes, only icon - I want to use it in iD presets

in general openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema#41 is tracking an attempt to ensure more unique and fitting icons

For example building=grandstand or indoor=corridor or shop=wigs or shop=nuts also lack dedicated icons (and I tried to find some and failed). If by any chance you would be interested in icon making this issue has more ideas. I added some recently, including some from Röntgen. Thanks for making them available!

See say openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema#2035 (comment)

[enzet]

Yeah, great! Let this issue be solely for building=service and we can add new issues later.

[matkoniecz]

Oh definitely - I really hate issues that suddenly is about 20 things at once, sorry for doing it.

I will open some additional issues later if that is fine with you and there is interest in making some icons.

[enzet]

I got some new icons:

Icon	Tags
	building=service
	building=service + utility=power
	building=service + utility=water

What do you think?

[matkoniecz]

First is great and I will definitely use it as soon as it becomes available!

For two next ones, not sure it's there dedicated iD preset for them, but I can imagine them useful. (is power stuff tagged as nodes within building area?)

[matkoniecz]

I can imagine also use for doorless version.

[enzet]

For two next ones, not sure it's there dedicated iD preset for them

Yeah, of course, I just tried some more shapes.

I can imagine also use for doorless version.

I'm not sure they work. Just without door it isn't recognisable as a building. And with gabled roof it is more like a normal house, not particularly a service one.

[matkoniecz]

Left is definitely not adding much, for right I think it may work given context but I will follow you as someone with more experience in icon design.

[enzet]

You're right that it's all about the context. I will add the first three icons to 0.14 version of Röntgen and just upload SVG files of other variants here, so you can use them or Röntgen variants, is it OK?