Conversation
tyrasd
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
👍 for the additional values, but I'm not quite sure what best to do with the rugby values. https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:sport%3Drugby says that
[…] a consensus has since emerged. It is advised to solely use the primary tag
sport=rugby. From there, if you know the version of rugby played at the location you are mapping, you can add a minor tag ofrugby=unionorrugby=league.
Although no source for where exactly this consensus was found is given (I assume it was a discussion on the talk mailing list), the sport=rugby approach does seem reasonable to me.
However, the wiki is not consistent on this: The Key:sport page does not list sport=rugby at all and the Tag:sport=rugby_* subpages do only slightly hint towards the sport=rugby tag and not list the values themselves as discouraged or deprecated. Further, usage numbers of the "old" tags do not seem to slow down. 🤔
Lastly, if we were going ahead with replacing sport=rugby_union with sport=rugby, I think we should also do the following:
- update the tags of the preset for Rugby League Field
- update the tags of the preset for Rugby Union Field
- add deprecation rules for
sport=rugby_leaguetosport=rugby+rugby=leagueand forsport=rugby_uniontosport=rugby+rugby=union
|
I've merged this without the proposed change to the |
Add some more sports, see #529
Replace
sport=rugby_unionwithsport=rugbyas recommended according to OSM wiki.